Selena Gomez and Justin Bieber Were Making Out

Fresh off reports of Justin Bieber failing to employ PUA tactics on a fellow Canadian, come new reports that he and Selena Gomez may be back on again. A witness saw them kissing at the Dream Hotel’s Marble Lane in New York City after Selena attended the UNICEF Snowflake Ball.

A source who sat close to their corner table tells PEOPLE they only stayed for 30 minutes before they left hand in hand. “It was just the two of them, sitting together,” the source says. “At first they were quietly talking and then they started kissing. They were smiling, definitely seemed happy!”

“They weren’t fighting,” another source told PEOPLE. PEOPLE

Well I for one am glad they clarified they weren’t fighting. I was a bit confused right after they said they were making out and smiling. I was like, “Huh? But tell me about the yelling! Was there any yelling?!”

Here’s Selena at the UNICEF Snowflake Ball earlier that day.